On this week’s episode of the Niche Pursuits podcast, Nick Loper and I discuss what it takes to build a successful podcast from scratch. Host of The Side Hustle Show since 2013, Nick has over 700 episodes and a staggering 35 million lifetime downloads.
We explore how he got started, what’s been key to his growth, how he thinks about audience engagement, and the practical steps to take to turn someone from a first-time listener into a raving fan. Whether you’re starting a new podcast or trying to grow an existing one, Nick shares insightful advice from years of experience.
Watch Full Episode
From Interest to Career
Nick started The Side Hustle Show in 2013 after leaving his corporate job to stay interesting and share tactical knowledge. At the time, he was already running a successful affiliate site in the shoe industry, but wanted a way to connect with other entrepreneurs.
He described his initial motivation: “I was legitimately worried. Would I run out of people to talk to?”
Thirteen years later, it’s still going strong, often with more potential guests than open slots. Its main stages are:
- Launched in 2013 with a $60 living room microphone.
- Passed 35 million downloads.
- It reaches about 100,000 unique listeners monthly.
- Released every Thursday with bonus episodes.
The Listener Pyramid: A Framework for Podcast Growth
Nick uses a four-step pyramid to conceptualize the listener journey:
- Strangers
- Listeners
- Subscribers
- The fans
Each level requires a different strategy to get people up the funnel. The challenge is that most of the world starts out as strangers who don’t even know podcasts exist.
Transition from Stranger to Listener
Discoverability and storytelling are critical to converting a stranger into a listener. Nick emphasizes:
- You need to “sell your content” with catchy headlines.
- Use podcast SEO techniques, including keywords in titles.
- Reach new audiences by guesting on other podcasts.
- Try paid promotions on podcast apps.
- Create headlines that communicate transformation, not just topics.
Examples of attention-grabbing early headlines:
- “From Heavy Metal College Band To Six Figure Agency”
- “A fiver salesman made enough to buy a house in his first year”
Converting Listeners to Subscribers
After someone listens to an episode, the next step is to build trust and consistency. Nick focuses on:
- Respect the listener’s time by keeping episodes short and starting quickly.
- Delivering on the episode’s promise.
- Marking past relevant episodes to continue listeners’ research.
It also uses lead magnets to collect emails:
- Episode-specific PDFs such as summaries or bonus tools.
- Personalized playlist builder on Side Hustle Show to recommend the biggest hits.
This move to intentionally grow his email list was a game changer. Within a year, he had about 1000 subscribers. After adding lead magnets and consistent calls to action, the list hit:
- 3000 for 3 months
- 6000 for 6 months
- 12,000 in a year
From Subscriber to Fan
Fans are at the top of the pyramid. These are the people:
- Share the show.
- Buy products or support sponsors.
- Engage with communities like his Facebook group.
- Listen to almost every episode.
Nick develops his fandom through the following means:
- Show continued publication and identity.
- Community touchpoints outside of the podcast (email, social groups).
- References and internal language (inspired by shows like My First Million).
- Mastermind offers products like groups.
- Encouraging word of mouth with remarkable stories.
“Every piece of content is designed to move people up that ladder,” he explains.
Flywheel: A Synced Podcast and Email List
Once a listener becomes an email subscriber, Nick uses his email list to bring people back to the podcast.
Its weekly newsletter is content-driven and offers:
- Text summary of episodes.
- Highlights and actionable ideas.
- Links to past episodes or related offers.
This back-and-forth flywheel helps keep listeners engaged while generating revenue through affiliate offers or product promotion.
Why Podcasting Wins as a Medium
Nick claims that podcasting builds deeper relationships than almost any other platform.
Podcast listeners:
- Spend more time with you (30-60 minutes a week).
- Often listen for months or years.
- They become loyal followers rather than blog or YouTube visitors.
Blog readers are transient. Podcast listeners stick around.
He noted that “Podcasts are hard to detect … but the devotion is unmatched.”
Monetization: Sponsorships and Add-ons
The Side Hustle Show makes between $10,000 and $20,000 a month from sponsorships alone. But Nick didn’t make money right away. It took years of consistency and growth.
His monetization journey:
- He started selling direct advertising space.
- He moved on to work with a podcast advertising agency (Young and Profitable Media).
- I’ve seen bigger deals, longer-term contracts, and more time to focus on content.
Sponsorship math:
- Mid-roll CPM is usually $25.
- Two ads per episode with 10,000 listeners = ~$500 per episode.
- With over 100,000 monthly listeners, Nick’s show has a strong influence.
Other income streams
Sponsorship is only one slice of the pie. Podcasts can also support businesses by:
- Selling products and services.
- Promotion of affiliate offers.
- Creating membership communities (like Patreon).
- Offers exclusive content or mastermind access.
- Lead generation for agencies or consulting.
One notable example that Nick shared was a Taylor Swift fan podcast that was making about $90,000 a month on Patreon.
What Works (and What Doesn’t)
After 700+ episodes, Nick sees clear patterns that resonate:
- Stories with clear transformation and innovation, like renting hot tubs or spinning lawnmowers.
- Actionable, tactical content on fluffy inspiration.
- Follow success stories from past guests or listeners.
- Keep production tight and introductions short.
He avoids long-winded theory or too much fluff, preferring practical insights that his audience can use immediately.
Final Thoughts
Nick Loper’s journey from hobbyist podcaster to full-time creator with millions of downloads shows that there’s still room for new voices if you approach podcasting with intention. His framework for moving people from strangers to fans provides a clear road map for long-term success.
Keynote speeches:
- Start with strong hooks and a story.
- Respect your audience’s time.
- Convert listeners to subscribers with custom lead magnets.
- Create a flywheel with email and podcast content.
- Earn money through sponsorships, products and communities.
Podcasting isn’t the easiest platform to grow, but for those who stick with it and play the long game, it can become a central pillar of a thriving online business.
Links and Resources
